I believe it’s time for black South Africans and their leadership to stop rolling over and playing possum. I believe it was an inappropriate ‘reconciliation’ gesture for President Thabo Mbeki to attend the funeral of tyrannical former South African State President P W Botha.
In many countries around the world, Botha would have been eligible for indictment in a Hague Tribunal for war crimes. The fact that he was allowed to live out his miserable, unrepentant life and die peacefully, albeit embittered, was his undeserved blessing.
I understand that there are protocol issues involved. I also understand that following Nelson Mandela’s lead on embracing and forgiving the former enemy, Mbeki chooses to tread the same path. But this is a little like Palestinian leadership attending the funeral of Ariel Sharon when he dies. Sometimes, people need the ethical and moral fibre to take and make a stand. And by staying away from Botha’s funeral, a telling statement would have been made. Botha didn’t voluntarily start any significant reformation process. His hand was forced by enlightened businesspeople engaging with the ANC in exile and an ungovernable country on his doorstep. Unctuous political magnanimity when a despot dies is not only misguided but plain dishonest. This man also remained an obdurate lightning-rod for people determined not to embrace democracy. The planet is well rid of him.
If I were a parent of one of the many thousands of children who died over the years under the jackboot of Botha’s police and other forces, I would be insulted and angry. Justice Malala wrote a superb article on the topic of Botha’s monstrous behaviour in the Sunday Times of 5th November 2006. Yesterday both Eleanor Sisulu and I, among many others, called into Xolani Gwala’s morning radio show on SAFM to express our outrage at the absurdity of this so-called ‘reconciliation gesture’.
Apartheid police general Gideon Nieuwoudt murdered among many other people, COSAS activist Siphiwo Mtimkhulu. In a nauseating attempt at ‘TV contrition’, Nieuwoudt begged forgiveness of Mtimkhulu’s parents. Sikhumbuzo Mtimkhulu, then 15, the victim’s son, was so enraged, he struck Nieuwoudt on the head with a vase, fracturing his skull. As Mtimkhulu’s senior said, ‘Mr. Nieuwoudt, you have come too late.’ Vlok-like foot-washing and other trite publicity efforts do little to assuage the grief and pain of thousands of parents who to this day still don’t know what happened to their children.
There are many young people today who were not born at the time of these atrocities. We have a social and moral obligation to ensure they don’t get victimised by revisionist history in an over-zealous and inappropriate quest for reconciliation.
I believe our South African political leadership needs to think more carefully before they toady in this manner again. Listening to the rabid white halfwits who called into yesterday’s radio program to defend Botha’s purported leadership and pseudo ‘legacy’ left no doubt that for some people, there is no such thing as reconciliation. They will carry their hatred and sense of ‘separateness’ to the grave – just like Botha did. Shame on them – and him.
Recent Comments